11-9-99

The Voice of Edwin is the weekly newsletter of the Edwin Lawrence Debate Union at the University of Vermont, an endowed co-curricular program which trains students in debating and sponsors national competition and community events. Alfred C. Snider is the Director. 802-656-0097 voice, 802-238-8345 mobile, 656-4275 fax, asnider@zoo.uvm.edu email, and http://debate.uvm.edu/ldu.html web site.
The LDU meets every Monday night at 6 PM at 475 Main Street.

SMASHING SUCCESS AT BINGHAMTON

Helen Morgan & Peter Winfield with awards

UVM #1 & #2 Junior Varsity Teams in the East
Novice Debaters Rake in Awards - 63-44 Record

Binghamton Univerisy hosted the CEDA East Regional Fall Championships this last weekend, and UVM not only attended in force but put togerther an extremely impressive competitive showing. Once again UVM had the largest squad BUT ALSO the best percentage record of any school.
The LDU took FIRST and SECOND place in the Junior Varsity division, as Helen Morgan and Peter Winfield on one side of the bracket and Jaime Robertson and Anthony Pagan on the other side of the bracket kept on winning until they met in the final round, where there was no debate. The astounding part was that one member of each of these teams was technically still a novice debater. Jaime and Anthony did it the hard way, losing their first three debates before winning their last five debates to share the title with Helen and Peter. Aaron Fishbone and Mark Douglas (Middlebury) were 3-3 in the JV division. Peter Winfield was the 6th speaker.
In the novice division SIX UVM teams were rated in the top 16 and advanced into the elimnination rounds after six preliminary debates. Two teams survived the first eliminaion round before losing in the quarterfinals, including Heather Towne & Allana Alexander as well as Meredith Parmett & Casey Gervais, who both ended up finishing Fifth in the novice division. Team bowing out in the octafinal round included Knops & Johnson, Miller & Robionson, Malley & Weidhorn, and Mullany & Chartan. UVM had seven of the top 15 speakers in the novice division. Tim Miller was First, Heather Towne was Fourth, Steve Gilpatric was Fifth, Allana Alexander was Sixth, Casey Gervais was Eighth, Liz Robinson was Thirteenth, and Jordan Clark was Fifteenth.
Only one UVM team had a record of less than 3-3, and they were only 2-4.
UVM Coach/Judge Rachel Hewitt finished second in the Outstanding Critic category.

LDU DEBATE FOR DIVERSITY DAY A SUCCESS

The LDU staged a public debate last week as part of "Building Our Community" Day at UVM last Wednesday. The debate took place in Ira Allen Chapel, with the topic, "Resolved: that substantial legal remedies should be adopted to compensate for white privilege." Aaron Fishbone and Peter Winfield were the affirmative, while Anthony Pagan and Helen Morgan were the negative. It was a spirited contest, with the cross examination periods being of special interest to the audience. The affirmative exposed the many elements of white privilege in modern America and called for the government toi do more, perhaps pass a new Civil Rights Act as was done in 1964. The negative advocated the "racial realism" of Derrick Bell [the law only hides oppression and quiesces the oppressed] and the ideas of bell hooks that all oppression is one [focusing just on race divides us against each other]. This provoked a lively discussion lasting long after the debate was over, with people even following the debaters over to Huber House to continue the discussion.
The video of the debate will soon be available at Debate Central Broadcasting [http://debate.uvm.edu/broadcast.html].


OKLAHOMA CITY, WAKE FOREST, COLUMBIA NEXT

Oklahoma City: Morgan-Snider, Pagan-Robertson, Massey & Parmett, leave office at 12 noon on Thursday.
Wake Forest: Morgan-Snider, Massey & Jacobson
Columbia (NYC): Serfer-Fishbone, Clark-McDonald, Douglas-Winfield, Pagan-Alexander, Gervais-Parmett, Thompson-Henchel, Gana-Engle, Jewers-Zerenner, and MORE!


RESEARCH

Threat answers - Greta, Allana, Helen
North Korea updates - Andy
Missile Defense - Tuna
TMD - Andy
2AC movements turns - Sarah
Socialism good - Anthony, Jackie
Chomsky processing - Daniel
Clinton link turn stories - Aaron, Andy
Delay CP answers - Sarah
Spanos answers - Helen
Taliban/India/Pakistan - Sarah
Deontology & Consequentialism - Tuna, Trond
Israel updates - Tim


HIGH SCHOOL WORKSHOP THIS SUNDAY

10 AM-5 PM
Ellis, Snider, McDonald, Jacobson, Lockwood, Fishbone


MEETINGS THIS WEEK
1NC-2NC-1NR TRAINING WED. 7 PM JACKIE
Gana-Engle catch up session Wed 5 PM


MIDWEST SWING 2000

TOURNAMENT DATES: Leave Burlington 1/2/2000, Arrive KC 1/3/2000, UMKC Tournament 1/4-6/2000, Wm Jewell Tournament 1/7-9/2000, Return to Burlington 1/11/2000.
Varsity & JV divisions. 9-3-6 10 prep Judge Preference.
PREPARATION
You should attend as much of the preparation period as you can. December, 18-19-20-21-22-23 Session 1, 27-28-29-30 Session 2.
SIGNING UP: Snider, Morgan, Lockwood, Winfield, Pagan, Gervais, Miller, Fishbone.


TOURNAMENT SCHEDULE
11/12-14 Oklahoma
11/20-21 Columbia
11/20-22 Wake Forest
UMKC 1/4-6
William Jewell 1/7-9


1999-2000 SeasonWINSLOSSES%
Previous958553%
Binghamton6344 
New Total158129 55%

Email us! Huber House