News from Vermont Debate AKA The Voice of Edwin is the weekly newsletter of the Edwin Lawrence Debate Union at the University of Vermont, an endowed co-curricular program which trains students in debating and sponsors national competition and community events. The newsletter is published every Tuesday during the school year and infrequently at other times. Alfred C. Snider is the Director. 802-656-0097 voice, 802-238-8345 mobile, 802-656-4275 fax, firstname.lastname@example.org email, and http://debate.uvm.edu/ldu.html web site.
| Kayce Massey, Helen Morgan Parmett, Emily Sanders | Jillian Marty, pal Jason Regnier |
DEMOUGEOT INVITATIONAL, UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS
The drive to Kansas
City has become a memory, although a vivid one. After over a dozen years of
driving from Vermont to Kansas City in January, the LDU rolled with the changes
in tournament schedules and attended the new two-tournament "swing"
in Texas. But this trip was a little different -- it involved flying. The bad
news before we left was that Edwin Owusu would not be able to make the trip
because of legal proceedings he needed to attend in support of hi family. Jillian
Marty, LDU President and Edwin's partner, was able to find a "hybrid"
partner from the University of Oklahoma, Rosie Lieurance, who needed a partner.
Given that former LDU coach Jackie Massey is now director at OU, it seemed like
a fortuitous move. Two other teams (Mimi Supernaw & Michael McMahan, along
with Kayce Massey & Emily Sanders, also made the trip along with coaches
Gordie Miller, Helen & Justin Morgan Parmett, and Tuna Snider, who was invited
to run the tab rooms at both tournaments.
The competition was difficult but the LDU fared well. Traditionally LDU novices debate on the "swing" in a higher division to gain experience, and this year was no exception. In the varsity division Jillian and Rosie lost a tough break round to miss the elimination rounds, but Rosie was arming up after three years away from debate. In JV the team of Kayce Massey and Emily Sanders reached the elimination rounds and both won speaker awards, an excellent performance. Mimi and Mike held their own and beat a number of more experienced teams but did not reach the elims.
The hospitality in Denton, Texas was stunning. Brian Lain and Jon Hines were fabulous hosts, providing local transportation, some free hotel rooms, and the best advice for dining and sight-seeing. Tuna found a fabulous used book store and the local culture was excellent. The tournament also featured an X-box video game tournament, but Gordie Miller was quickly eliminated in the Madden football category.
| Alumnae Rae Lynn Schwartz | Mike McMahan's new look | Pre-round discussion |
FEAR AND LOATHING IN DALLAS, UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT DALLAS
Without any rest it
was on to the University of Texas at Dallas for the next tournament, to complete
six straight days of debating. The squad moved to Dallas from Denton. The varsity
division was larger and more competitive, while the JV division stayed about
the same. This time Jillian and Rosie won their crucial break debates and reached
the elimination rounds, where they were unfortunately defeated by the University
of Texas. Neither young team cleared in the JV division, but Mike and Mimi missed
clearing by half a speaker point, but Kayce Massey once again received a speaker
award, indicating that this swing was a real turning point in her debate performances.
Once again, the hospitality was fantastic, and Chris Burk and Scott Herndon of UTD did everything they could to make us feel welcome. The poker tournament was interesting, and Mike McMahan did get involved the second night. Adam Lee of Rochester won the official poker tournament.
Special thanks to Sam Miller for driving us down to Boston and to Charlie Hoag for picking us up.
| UVM & Claremont | 15 minutes prep for rounds | Montreal City Hall |
NORTH AMERICAN WOMEN'S OPEN, CONCORDIA UNIVERSITY, MONTREAL, CANADA
in Montreal invited us up to join them at the North American Women's Open held
the weekend of the 16-18 January. The tournament was to be held in Canadian
parliamentary debate format. Jillian Marty and Teresa Hill wanted to go even
though neither of them had ever been involved with parliamentary debate before.
After some training the team went up in Tuna's VW bug to learn about the world
of Canadian parliamentary debating.
While there the UVM team was lucky enough to room with Sarah and Jenny from Claremont McKenna College in California, so it was good to be with friends. 42 teams attended, with four being from the USA and the rest from Canada. The food, accommodations, and hospitality were fantastic. Canadian parliamentary debating was challenging because there are many conventions but none of them are written down, which made adaptation difficult. "Manner" seemed to be given more weight in making decisions than "matter." Teresa entered the public speaking contest and missed being in the final round by .5 points. Jillian indicated after that she preferred policy debate.
The tournament provided housing in the Ritz-Carlton, excellent meals, and a final round in the debating chamber of the Montreal city hall. We appreciate the special invitation by Concordia.
| Brian Cole '03 | Jill Witney '03 |
Two long serving members
of the LDU stopped by the office as they left town to say goodbye. We are proud
of both of them and know that they will be successful.
BRIAN COLE began as a novice debater and finished as a coach. His first tournament was actually novice nationals. He returned in one year to reach the final round and capture second place at novice nationals. He received many team and speaker awards before acting as a coach in the Fall of 2003 as he finished his degree. Brian has already started coaching at Wichita State University in Kansas, where he will be a graduate assistant and work towards a masters degree in speech communication.
JILL WITNEY also began as a novice debater but was recruited through the Rhetoric of Reggae Music class taught by Tuna. She debated as a novice and finished as a coach. Jill had an outstanding energy for debate that propelled her towards helping many others people -- someone who needed a partner at the last minute, someone was having difficulty and needed a positive conversation, updates on evidence and arguments. She debated successfully in the novice and junior varsity divisions before turning to coaching. She was twice a TA in the Fundamentals of Debate class. This last fall was one of her most active at coaching and judging. Jill will be taking a full-time position at Dartmouth's medical center in the implementation of a major federal grant.
PAM PECK from the 80's
drops us a line:
" We are still living in funky inner southeast Portland. (Benjamin attends kindergarten at the neighborhood elementary school. Tom is a tech writer at Oracle.) I'm working, a civilized 4-days per week, as a public affairs coordinator for Metro, the only directly-elected regional government in the U.S. Metro protects open space and parks, plans for land use and transportation, and manages garbage disposal and recycling for 1.3 million residents in three counties and 24 cities in the Portland, Oregon, region. I manage a variety of projects for the agency -- one of the most interesting is working with independent filmmakers and community groups to produce a television program and website that will explore transportation issues through the personal stories of 17 families/individuals. I volunteer one morning a week at Ben's school and a couple of times a month at KBOO (our community radio station) hosting an eclectic folk music program."
If you come to Burlington drop by 475 Main Street, see Huber House, and get your photo in the newsletter!
LDU BANQUET - Dinner, Saturday, May 1, 2004.
Research Director is Jillian Marty. Assignments accepted must be completed.
ASSIGNMENTS POSTED IN OFFICE. DUE NEXT WEEK, TUES NIGHT 9 PM
NOW WITH 278
Watch Flashpoint from your computer screen whenever you want! You will need RealPlayer installed on your computer to become a part of our growing audience. Here are some recent programs now available at http://debate.uvm.edu/flashpoint.html. Watch on Burlington Channel 15 Wednesday 12:30 PM, Thursday 10 PM, Saturday 1 PM.
Next tapings: 2/7, 2/21, 3/27, 4/3, 5/1 all Saturdays.
UVM DEBATE WAS #10 IN THE CEDA NATIONAL SWEEPSTAKES FOR 2002-2003.
|LAST YEAR AT THIS TIME||211||240||46.7%|